Dolby DTS and 5.1 Surround Test with Steely Dan
Last night I spent a thoroughly enjoyable evening with Walter Becker and Donald Fagen of Steely Dan and their band. Well, not exactly, but as close as you can get without being there. The DVD is Steely Dan: Two Against Nature, recorded in 2000. This was the ultimate test of my system - a live studio recording in Dolby 5.1, cranked up to live levels.
The system that I built has four outboard amps. Total system power output including surround amps and subwoofer totals to around 2000 watts of power. For left and right speakers I have constructed dipole prototypes with a 10" mid-bass, 6" midrange and for highs, dual dipole planer tweeters. Imaging is pinpoint accurate, due to the openness of the dipoles, the planer tweeters and the room treatment. As you can see, behind each of the dipoles are two large diffusers that break up the back wave and diffuse it out to the side, which creates a much more natural ambience and sound field. Speakers do not sound boxy or blurry - just pure audio reproduced as close as possible to the original. Here is a side view of the dipoles - you can get a better idea of how they are positioned relative to the diffusers.
Subwoofer is an infinite baffle type, ported out through the ceiling from the attic. The sub consists of two 18" Peavey Low-Rider drivers mounted in a manifold. Once again, no box to influence or color the sound. Power to the sub is about 800 watts and drivers are wired in parallel and about 98 db efficient, so 800 watts is more than enough. Midbass and midrange drivers are just about as efficient, around 97-98 db/watt. And because the cabinets are dipole, sound from the backside increases the apparent loudness in the room. Midbass and midrange drivers are feed 150 watts, so no clipping is ever heard.
Above Left: 3 way active crossover by Behringer on top of Harmon-Kardon HT receiver. The funky little dome-shaped unit is the Sonic Impact tripath amp that drives the planer tweeters. Above Right: Behringer EuroPower EP1500 to drive the dual 18" subs. This is tucked away in the closet below the subs, and it needs to be isolated because of the noise from the cooling fans.
This system has plenty of headroom and seems to be overkill for my small room, but in reality is not overkill - it sounds like the control room of a very high-end recording studio. Kick and snare drums sound real, the punch, dynamics and snap of the snare is incredible. The only limiting factor is the recording. The Two Against Nature DVD is incredibly well produced, on par with other offering by the Steely Dan group of sound engineers. The disc was recorded live in New York at the Sony Studios and should be in every Home Theater builders inventory of test discs.

